METRO fellows taking pitches

JF
jenna freedman
Tue, Feb 2, 2016 12:07 AM

Should we put a proposal in for METRO Fellows to do some LOD zine union
catalog work? http://fellowship.metro.org/?q=node/4

Or would we risk their coming up with something cool--to them, and useless
to us that we might feel pressured to take because it would represent a lot
of work?

The other wrinkle is that I'd have to find two other METRO member orgs to
partner with. NYU would be a logical choice because of Lisa Darms
http://www.nyu.edu/library/bobst/research/fales/riotgrrrltest.html's
involvement in the zine librarian community. I could talk to NYPL
http://www.nypl.org/about/divisions/general-research-division/periodicals-room/zines,
which has a long-standing zine collection. I'm not sure what's up with
zines at Brooklyn College http://brooklyncollegezines.commons.gc.cuny.edu/
and Pratt http://libguides.pratt.edu/zines. I'd want to bring in ABC No
Rio http://www.abcnorio.org/facilities/zine_library.html and maybe Silent
Barn http://ditkoexclamation.tumblr.com/.

I don't know where the fellows come from or what their skills are.

Jenna

--
http://lowereastsidelibrarian.info
http://zines.barnard.edu
http://leslzine.storenvy.com
she, her, hers


Zlunioncat mailing list
Zlunioncat@lists.qzap.org
http://lists.qzap.org/listinfo.cgi/zlunioncat-qzap.org

Should we put a proposal in for METRO Fellows to do some LOD zine union catalog work? http://fellowship.metro.org/?q=node/4 Or would we risk their coming up with something cool--to them, and useless to us that we might feel pressured to take because it would represent a lot of work? The other wrinkle is that I'd have to find two other METRO member orgs to partner with. NYU would be a logical choice because of Lisa Darms <http://www.nyu.edu/library/bobst/research/fales/riotgrrrltest.html>'s involvement in the zine librarian community. I could talk to NYPL <http://www.nypl.org/about/divisions/general-research-division/periodicals-room/zines>, which has a long-standing zine collection. I'm not sure what's up with zines at Brooklyn College <http://brooklyncollegezines.commons.gc.cuny.edu/> and Pratt <http://libguides.pratt.edu/zines>. I'd want to bring in ABC No Rio <http://www.abcnorio.org/facilities/zine_library.html> and maybe Silent Barn <http://ditkoexclamation.tumblr.com/>. I don't know where the fellows come from or what their skills are. Jenna -- http://lowereastsidelibrarian.info http://zines.barnard.edu http://leslzine.storenvy.com she, her, hers _______________________________________________ Zlunioncat mailing list Zlunioncat@lists.qzap.org http://lists.qzap.org/listinfo.cgi/zlunioncat-qzap.org
HM
Honor Moody
Tue, Feb 2, 2016 1:58 AM

It sounds like its the inaugural cohort, and the fellowship applications
don't open for another 6 weeks,  so maybe they don't have a clear sense of
Fellow demographics themselves? With the fellowship just beginning, things
may be more fluid in a way that benefits us, on the other hand, if there a
flaws in the program management, will be the beta testers.

Also, it sounds like they're into matching people with similar projects,
which could be cool, but could also be not really what we're looking for.
There's already one pitch, http://fellowship.metro.org/node/21 that's
looking for something like a "catalog."

That said, I feel like our underlying process is about asking really good
questions about what we want from a catalog and how to get it, but my sense
of the feedback we got at Mashcat was that there maybe other ways to get
where we'd like to be that aren't so obvious from our perspective, so
there's probably something to be said for asking the fundamental questions
to an outside audience.  Based on the other pitches so far and a not too
urgent deadline, this seems to be something we could put together without a
ton of effort on our part.

H

On Mon, Feb 1, 2016 at 7:07 PM, jenna freedman leslzine@gmail.com wrote:

Should we put a proposal in for METRO Fellows to do some LOD zine union
catalog work? http://fellowship.metro.org/?q=node/4

Or would we risk their coming up with something cool--to them, and useless
to us that we might feel pressured to take because it would represent a lot
of work?

The other wrinkle is that I'd have to find two other METRO member orgs to
partner with. NYU would be a logical choice because of Lisa Darms
http://www.nyu.edu/library/bobst/research/fales/riotgrrrltest.html's
involvement in the zine librarian community. I could talk to NYPL
http://www.nypl.org/about/divisions/general-research-division/periodicals-room/zines,
which has a long-standing zine collection. I'm not sure what's up with
zines at Brooklyn College
http://brooklyncollegezines.commons.gc.cuny.edu/ and Pratt
http://libguides.pratt.edu/zines. I'd want to bring in ABC No Rio
http://www.abcnorio.org/facilities/zine_library.html and maybe Silent
Barn http://ditkoexclamation.tumblr.com/.

I don't know where the fellows come from or what their skills are.

Jenna

--
http://lowereastsidelibrarian.info
http://zines.barnard.edu
http://leslzine.storenvy.com
she, her, hers


Zlunioncat mailing list
Zlunioncat@lists.qzap.org
http://lists.qzap.org/listinfo.cgi/zlunioncat-qzap.org

It sounds like its the inaugural cohort, and the fellowship applications don't open for another 6 weeks, so maybe they don't have a clear sense of Fellow demographics themselves? With the fellowship just beginning, things may be more fluid in a way that benefits us, on the other hand, if there a flaws in the program management, will be the beta testers. Also, it sounds like they're into matching people with similar projects, which could be cool, but could also be not really what we're looking for. There's already one pitch, http://fellowship.metro.org/node/21 that's looking for something like a "catalog." That said, I feel like our underlying process is about asking really good questions about what we want from a catalog and how to get it, but my sense of the feedback we got at Mashcat was that there maybe other ways to get where we'd like to be that aren't so obvious from our perspective, so there's probably something to be said for asking the fundamental questions to an outside audience. Based on the other pitches so far and a not too urgent deadline, this seems to be something we could put together without a ton of effort on our part. H On Mon, Feb 1, 2016 at 7:07 PM, jenna freedman <leslzine@gmail.com> wrote: > Should we put a proposal in for METRO Fellows to do some LOD zine union > catalog work? http://fellowship.metro.org/?q=node/4 > > Or would we risk their coming up with something cool--to them, and useless > to us that we might feel pressured to take because it would represent a lot > of work? > > The other wrinkle is that I'd have to find two other METRO member orgs to > partner with. NYU would be a logical choice because of Lisa Darms > <http://www.nyu.edu/library/bobst/research/fales/riotgrrrltest.html>'s > involvement in the zine librarian community. I could talk to NYPL > <http://www.nypl.org/about/divisions/general-research-division/periodicals-room/zines>, > which has a long-standing zine collection. I'm not sure what's up with > zines at Brooklyn College > <http://brooklyncollegezines.commons.gc.cuny.edu/> and Pratt > <http://libguides.pratt.edu/zines>. I'd want to bring in ABC No Rio > <http://www.abcnorio.org/facilities/zine_library.html> and maybe Silent > Barn <http://ditkoexclamation.tumblr.com/>. > > I don't know where the fellows come from or what their skills are. > > Jenna > > -- > http://lowereastsidelibrarian.info > http://zines.barnard.edu > http://leslzine.storenvy.com > she, her, hers > > _______________________________________________ > Zlunioncat mailing list > Zlunioncat@lists.qzap.org > http://lists.qzap.org/listinfo.cgi/zlunioncat-qzap.org > > _______________________________________________ Zlunioncat mailing list Zlunioncat@lists.qzap.org http://lists.qzap.org/listinfo.cgi/zlunioncat-qzap.org